We apologize but are fully booked through December 16th and will be closed December 24-26. Please note that our new hours are Sunday-Thursday from 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. and Friday & Saturday 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Please order ahead to ensure availability. Cakes and custom cookies must be ordered 1 week in advance, cupcakes and pies 48 hours and cookies of over 2 dozen 24 hours. The Better Crumb™ is a licensed home bakery. All of our products are baked by a professional pastry chef. We are NYS safety certified. Free local delivery to Stuytown, Peter Cooper Village and Gramercy (choose "pick up" and leave a delivery note at checkout) For areas outside our free delivery zone pick up is available or email us for delivery options and fees before placing an order at thebettercrumb@gmail.com

Best Sellers Mix

Best Sellers Mix

Regular price
$40.00
Sale price
$40.00
Regular price
Sold out
Unit price
per 

Cookies are baked to order and can take up to 2-3 hours so please order early to ensure same day delivery/pick up) Orders of 2 dozen or more require 24 hours notice. No refunds for same day orders.

Free local delivery to Stuytown, Peter Cooper Village and Gramercy (choose "pick up" and leave a delivery note at checkout) For areas outside our free delivery zone, pick up is available or email us for delivery options and fees before placing an order at thebettercrumb@gmail.com.

Sometimes me think, "What is a friend?" And then me think, "Friend is someone to share last cookie with." - Cookie Monster

Contains a mixture of Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Peanut Butter and Oatmeal Raisin. A great gift for anyone who loves cookies or a perfect choice if you are trying our cookies for the first time.

Please leave a note at checkout if you would like a different combination.

See individual cookies for ingredients.