We apologize but are fully booked through May 25th. We will be closed May 15-26. Please note that our new hours are Sunday-Wednesday from 3:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m. and Thursday-Saturday 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Please order ahead to ensure availability. Cakes, custom cookies, cupcakes and pies must be ordered at least 1 week in advance and drop cookies now require 24 hours advance notice. The Better Crumb™ is a licensed home bakery. All of our products are baked by a professional pastry chef. We are NYS safety certified. Pick up is located at 21st & First Ave (see confirmation for details) Free delivery for orders of $40 or more to Stuytown/PCV during our open hours only. Email us with any questions at thebettercrumb@gmail.com

Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Custom Cookies

Custom Cookies

Regular price
$150.00
Sale price
$150.00
Regular price
Sold out
Unit price
per 

Custom cookie orders must be placed 1 week in advance. Please e-mail thebettercrumb@gmail.com for pricing and a payment link before ordering. Cancellations need to be made 48 hours in advance. 

Have you ever bitten into one of those beautifully decorated sugar cookies, only to find it tastes like cardboard and the icing is as hard as concrete? We have! We promise these cookies taste as good as they look... no, actually better! We use our favorite butter cookie here with a delicious icing that hardens just the right amount - no tooth chipping here!

Ingredients: flour, butter, sugar, egg yolks, vanilla, salt. Icing: confectioner's sugar, meringue powder, lemon juice, vanilla, food coloring.