Cookies are baked to order and can take up to 2-3 hours so please order early to ensure same day delivery/pick up). Orders of 2 dozen or more require 24 hours notice. No refunds for same day orders.
Free local delivery to Stuytown, Peter Cooper Village and Gramercy (choose "pick up" and leave a delivery note at checkout) For areas outside our free delivery zone, pick up is available or email us for delivery options and fees before placing an order at thebettercrumb@gmail.com.
"You can't make everyone happy. You aren't a jar of peanut butter.'"
After testing dozens of recipes (it got to the point where I had to start prying family members mouths open to shove cookies in) and getting feedback like "my grandma's were better... not peanut buttery enough... too dry... too crumbly... too sandy... too soft... good.... and pretty good" I felt like giving up. "Pretty good" is not part of my vocabulary. They say a great peanut butter cookie can only be made with Jif or Skippy. Enter Cream-Nut peanut butter (go Michigan!) I finally heard the words I had been waiting for... "they are perfect!!!" Music to my ears.
Flour, brown sugar, sugar, butter, crunchy all-natural peanut butter (peanuts, salt), eggs, almond milk, vanilla, baking soda, baking powder salt.